What happens to a business in a property settlement?

When one or both parties own a business, it can be one of the most valuable and contentious parts of a property settlement. Unlike a house or a bank account, however, a business rarely has an obvious value. Two accountants can look at the same business and reach very different conclusions depending on the methodology and assumptions they use.

Three questions commonly drive the dispute: What is the business worth? Who really controls it? And why are the parties’ numbers so far apart?

Understanding these issues early can make a significant difference to the cost, timing and outcome of a property settlement.

How is a business treated in a property settlement?

A business interest held by either party will generally need to be identified and valued as part of the property settlement. Exactly what is valued depends on the legal structure through which the business operates.

The Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) expressly sets out the framework for determining property settlements, beginning with identifying the parties’ existing legal and equitable rights and interests in property and their liabilities. [1]

The treatment of a business will depend on its structure:

  • Sole trader. The business assets and liabilities are held personally by the owner. Any transferable or saleable goodwill may also have value.

  • Company. Ordinarily, it is the party’s shares or other interest in the company that is relevant, rather than the company’s assets being treated as though they were personally owned by the shareholder. Director or shareholder loan accounts may also need to be identified and valued.

  • Partnership. The value of a party’s partnership interest will depend on matters including the partnership’s assets, liabilities and goodwill and the terms of any partnership agreement.

  • Trust. Trust structures require careful analysis. Depending on the terms of the trust, the identity and powers of the trustee and appointor, the history of distributions and the practical reality of control, the trust assets may be treated as property or the party’s interest may instead be relevant as a financial resource.

Many businesses use a combination of companies, trusts and other entities. The first task is therefore often to map the structure and identify who owns and controls what.

How is a business valued?

Where the parties cannot agree on the value of a business, they will often jointly appoint an independent forensic accountant or business valuer. If proceedings have commenced, the Family Law Rules contain specific provisions dealing with expert evidence and single expert witnesses. [2]

The appropriate valuation methodology will depend on the nature of the business. Common approaches include:

  • Capitalisation of future maintainable earnings. The valuer estimates the level of profit the business can reasonably be expected to generate on an ongoing basis. That figure is then adjusted and capitalised using a multiple that reflects matters such as risk, growth prospects and the nature of the business. This method is commonly used for established and profitable businesses.

  • Net assets. The value of the business’s assets is assessed less its liabilities. This method may be more appropriate for asset-heavy businesses or businesses that are not consistently profitable.

  • Market evidence. The valuer may consider sales of comparable businesses or, where available, previous arm’s-length transactions involving shares or interests in the business.

What about goodwill?

Goodwill can be one of the most contested aspects of a business valuation.

Commercial goodwill that attaches to the business itself, such as its brand, location, systems, customer base or recurring revenue, may have substantial value.

Personal goodwill can be different. If customers engage the business principally because of one person’s particular skill, reputation or relationships, some or all of that goodwill may not be transferable to a purchaser. That distinction can have a significant effect on value.

What about tax?

Tax consequences also require careful consideration.

Whether a potential capital gains tax liability or other tax cost should affect the value ultimately attributed to an asset will depend on the circumstances, including the likelihood of the relevant tax liability actually arising and the way in which the business or interest is ultimately dealt with.

Who really controls the business?

Legal ownership is not always the end of the inquiry.

The Court may examine not only the formal structure recorded in company and trust documents, but also the practical reality of who exercises control.

This can be particularly important with discretionary trusts. Matters that may be relevant include:

  • who is the trustee;

  • who holds the power to appoint or remove the trustee;

  • who is the appointor and whether that position can be changed;

  • who makes decisions concerning trust distributions;

  • the history of distributions;

  • who controls the business bank accounts;

  • who authorises payments;

  • who appoints or removes directors;

  • whether other shareholders, trustees or beneficiaries genuinely exercise independent control; and

  • what has happened in practice, rather than simply what the documents say.

The High Court’s decision in Kennon v Spry is an important example of the Court’s treatment of assets held within a discretionary trust in family law property proceedings.

Companies are also carefully examined. Shareholdings and directorships are important, but so too are voting rights, shareholder agreements, loan accounts and the practical management of the company.

Where a business or trust involves other people, such as parents, siblings, business partners, co-directors or other beneficiaries, their interests also need to be considered. In some cases it may be necessary for a third party to be joined to the proceedings. The Court’s financial proceedings practice direction requires all necessary parties to be included in an application.

Why are the parties’ business valuations so far apart?

It is not uncommon for one party to believe a business is worth several times the amount suggested by the other.

Often, the difference comes down to the assumptions used in the valuation rather than disagreement about the business’s raw financial figures.

Common areas of disagreement include:

  • Normalising profit. A valuer may adjust reported profit to determine the business’s true ongoing earnings. For example, personal expenses paid by the business may be added back, while a commercial salary may be substituted for an owner who pays themselves an unusually high or low wage.

  • The valuation multiple. Relatively small differences in assumptions about risk, growth and the appropriate multiple can have a significant impact on value.

  • Goodwill. The parties may disagree about how much goodwill belongs to the business, whether there is goodwill, and if there is how much is attributable personally to the owner.

  • Recent trading. A significant increase or decline in revenue may raise questions about whether the change is temporary or represents the business’s likely future performance.

  • Incomplete information. A valuation is only as reliable as the information provided to the valuer. Missing or inaccurate records can significantly complicate the process.

What financial disclosure is required?

Full financial disclosure is particularly important where one party operates or controls the business.

The duty of financial disclosure in property matters is expressly contained in the Family Law Act 1975[3]. Depending on the business structure and the issues in dispute, relevant documents may include:

  • financial statements;

  • business and company tax returns;

  • Business Activity Statements;

  • management accounts;

  • general ledgers;

  • business bank and credit card statements;

  • shareholder and director loan accounts;

  • trust deeds and variations;

  • trustee and company resolutions;

  • payroll records;

  • related-party transactions; and

  • material contracts and other documents relevant to the business’s ongoing earnings.

The business owner or controlling party will often have far greater access to this information than their former partner.

A failure to provide proper disclosure can have serious consequences, including procedural orders, costs consequences and, depending on the available evidence, findings that are unfavourable to the non-disclosing party.

What if you disagree with the expert’s valuation?

A single expert’s report does not necessarily end the debate.

Depending on the circumstances and the applicable Court rules and orders, the parties may be able to put written questions to the expert about their report, methodology or assumptions.[4]

In an appropriate case, a party may also seek permission to rely on evidence from another expert. This can add considerable cost and is not automatic.

Ultimately, if the matter proceeds to a hearing, it is the Court that determines the value it accepts.

What if the business value changes after separation?

Business values do not stand still simply because a couple separates.

Revenue may increase or fall, a major customer may be gained or lost, economic conditions may change, or one party may continue to work in and develop the business after separation.

This makes the timing of a valuation important. A property settlement generally requires consideration of the parties’ financial circumstances at or around the time the matter is determined, rather than simply fixing the value of the business at the date of separation.

Significant changes in value after separation may also raise questions about why that change occurred and the contributions made by each party during the post-separation period.

For business owners in particular, maintaining reliable financial and operational records from the date of separation can therefore be critical.

Who keeps the business?

Where it is commercially and financially workable, a common outcome is for the party who operates the business to retain it, with the other party receiving additional cash or other assets as part of the overall property settlement.

Maintaining the business as a going concern can benefit both parties, particularly where a sale would destroy value. Whether one party can retain the business, however, will depend on matters including:

  • the value attributed to it;

  • the amount and nature of the other assets available for division;

  • cash flow;

  • borrowing and refinancing capacity;

  • tax consequences; and

  • whether the retaining party can fund any payment required to the other party.

A settlement may therefore involve refinancing, staged payments or the transfer of other property to enable one party to retain the business.

Avoiding double counting (“double-dipping”)

Care is also needed to avoid double counting.

Where the value attributed to a business reflects its anticipated future earnings, care must be taken before relying on those same earnings again when considering the business owner’s future financial circumstances.

Whether this amounts to impermissible “double dipping” will depend on the valuation methodology and the facts of the particular case.

What should you do if a business is involved in your property settlement?

If you own or run the business

  • Gather complete financial records early. As a starting point, this will commonly include at least three years of financial statements and tax returns, together with current management accounts and BAS.

  • Keep business and personal expenses clearly separated, particularly after separation.

  • Avoid unusual transactions, large drawings, restructures or transfers of assets without obtaining advice.

  • Do not deliberately reduce profits or alter the way the business operates in an attempt to reduce its apparent value. A forensic accountant can adjust reported earnings, and unusual post-separation transactions or changes in remuneration may attract considerable scrutiny.

  • Speak with your accountant and family lawyer early, but remember that an expert appointed to provide valuation evidence must act independently.

If your former partner owns or runs the business

  • Record what you know about the business structure, associated companies and trusts, bank accounts and key people involved.

  • Retain copies of financial documents to which you have lawful access.

  • Seek advice early about the documents that should be disclosed and whether further information needs to be obtained through the Court process.

  • Do not assume that the balance sheet tells you what the business is worth. A profitable business may have substantial goodwill even where its tangible net assets are relatively modest.

  • If you are concerned that assets may be transferred, dissipated or otherwise dealt with before settlement, obtain advice promptly about whether protective orders or other steps are appropriate.

Speak with an experienced family law team

A business can make a property settlement considerably more complex. The legal ownership of the business is only the starting point. Its value, the structures through which it operates, who controls those structures, the quality of the financial disclosure and the tax consequences of any proposed settlement can all affect the outcome.

Together with my KHQ Family & Relationship Law team, we work with forensic accountants, business valuers and tax advisers to help our clients understand the real value of business interests and develop a practical strategy for resolving their property settlement. If you are thinking about separating, even if you have not decided, an early conversation gives you options you may not have later.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. It reflects the law as at November 2026. You should obtain advice about your specific circumstances.

 
Previous
Previous

What happens to an inheritance or family gift after separation?

Next
Next

When a child refuses to spend time with a parent: what does it really mean?